>> (p.1)
    Author Topic: Bitcoins on Mars  (Read 9848 times)
    RHorning (OP)
    Full Member
    ***
    Offline Offline

    Activity: 224
    Merit: 141


    View Profile
    July 21, 2010, 04:00:54 AM
     #1

    I mentioned this in another thread, but I think it has some validity in a general discussion here:

    How would you move Bitcoins between the Earth and Mars?

    I think the short answer:  You can't.  At least with the current design of the network.

    Mind you, I'm not suggesting here that we need to deal with a science fiction eventuality that won't happen for years or even centuries, but I think it may have other side applications even for more mundane uses here on the Earth.  I'm suggesting this mainly as a thought experiment and perhaps a work around for something constrained under these kind of conditions.

    The main issue here is the several minutes it takes for round-trip communications (up to about a half-hour or perhaps a bit more with relays) between the Earth and Mars.... constrained by the speed of light.  Unless you have a non-Einsteinian physics that allows you to do communications at FTL velocities, this is something that simply has to be dealt with in that sort of situation.

    I could imagine for a more mundane terrestrial application to be trying to carry on a transaction where networks might be separated at some point  (a couple of "different" bitcoin networks get put into temporary "islands" before they can merge their transaction/coin generation data together) or perhaps you are trying to conduct a transaction "off network" where the transaction wouldn't get recorded on the larger network as a whole.

    For the sake of this discussion, consider that most of the nodes involved here are "honest" and trying in earnest to conduct real transfers of Bitcoins, so this isn't necessarily a direct attack by any particular node.  This perhaps could be an attack on the network itself or a natural/man-made disaster of some sort (nuclear war, hurricanes, tsunami, mega-volcano, meteor strike) that causes significant communications disruptions where communications between groups of nodes is broken off for an extended period of time.

    How would two groups of nodes "re-sync" to each other in a situation like this if some sort of communication bridge could be established but would take significant periods of time to happen?

    Yes, I'm being serious here too, and the issues involved have an impact on the performance and stability of this as an alternate currency.
Page 1
Viewing Page: 1