Honestly, removing the faucet is a terrible idea. It's how I got into gambling and using PrimeDice. I've lost a fair bit (.5 or so) BTC in it, but it was fun

.
Removing the faucet would cause a lot of users to move and put their coins into another gambling website that does offer a faucet, and they'll eventually gamble their BTC there.
Since you say that support is the issue, why not have a separate team of volunteer community members to answer these tickets? You could create a "Category" section for support requests or have them email
faucet@primedice.com instead of
support@primedice.com.
Or, make it so that you can only use the faucet once per x amount of time, or make it so you can use the faucet say, 10 or 20 times, and then you'd have to deposit .001 BTC or something to continue using it.
Rather than remove the faucet, explore alternative solutions. It'll be good for us all

.