<<  >> (p.5)
    Author Topic: problem with off-chain "provably fair" games  (Read 4832 times)
    knowitnothing
    Sr. Member
    ****
    Offline

    Activity: 294
    Merit: 250


    View Profile
    October 18, 2013, 06:52:02 AM
     #81

    Each and every roll has to have some kind of external input that the casino cannot predict, even if the user is "lazy" and leaves the same settings in place.  I believe forcing the user to change their seed every time would work.

    Changing the user seed every time doesn't solve anything, it just complicates the situation for the user to check for provably fair results (no need to make up what you believe this is, this has been discussed several times in this same forum, even outside this thread). Never forget that the server is ultimately responsible for reporting back the results.

    Suppose you're changing the user seed before every bet. The system can just "shutdown the server, disconnect the user, etc" (I forgot the exact words you used) after it obtains the outcome of a bet, but before it sends back to the user. When the system "resumes its operation", it can just make up some excuse. Since the user seed is always changing, the earlier one you used would've changed now and the new bet will produce a different result (hopefully one that doesn't make the server shutdown, disconnect the user, etc). If you are not keeping track of every user seed change (lazy user as you say), you won't even know which seeds you used and you might not be able to check the results later.


    if there is a 100% provably fair option why not implement it? because it is to complicated? or there is no need to implement it because the players are not asking for it? IMHO the house/casino should implement the 100% provably fair option if it exists.

    First we need to understand which part of it is not provably fair, otherwise there is no hope to implement it. What I see some people suggesting is not provably fair (like using, or claiming to use, an external service), and that's why you won't see any of the current provably fair games implementing that.
Page 4
Viewing Page: 5