Just got a response from Alpha-t regarding my asking for refund options. According to the e-mail since I placed the order > 5 months ago I basically don't have any :/
Kind of curious given I made final 70% payment within the last few weeks. Getting the feeling I won't be seeing these satoshi's again :/
It's right in the contract:
" You may cancel your order at any point within the five month period following the date on which we received payment of your deposit (provided that your product has not yet shipped)."
Hey, Its About Sharing, looks like they do plan on enforcing that pesky ole contract after all huh? Imagine that.
Brian, if you recall, I asked you about this here: "I'm not sure about the way the contract is worded. Can you post what it is that you are talking about?"
https://bt.irlbtc.com/view/314402.msg7454111#msg7454111 And now you are taking a shot at me?
You really seem to like to jab at me. I asked you a few questions on that same page (here
https://bt.irlbtc.com/view/314402.msg7449856#msg7449856) and you seemed to just jump over them. Since you're in a playing mood, maybe you can have a go at them now. Here, at least answer the one that mattered.
In your reply to diego2000 you state "Put another way, say YOU had a couple hundred 250Mh/s miners right now. Would you really head down to Fed Ex tomorrow and ship them off, or would you wait a while, make some money, and THEN sell them? All due respect, I think it is very naive to think they would leave all that money on the table." This sounds like something you would do and you are projecting it onto others. I would ship them off because I honor my word. Life is not about making as much money as I can. We reap what we sow. I'm not sure how you can judge AT when you are basically saying you would do something that you are accusing them of, because, well, it is the "natural" thing to do.
To be honest, I completely missed your post. To answer your questions, the concerning parts are:
1. Regarding the delivery date, they keep promising these will ship in July. But, if you read the terms of the contract, there is NO delivery date to be found anywhere! The *closest* stating a delivery date is as follows:
"We are currently working hard to ensure that the products will be available for delivery as soon as possible, and hope to have them available for shipping in the second or third quarter of 2014"
Now, that isn't a guarantee. They could ship these things next year and still claim they did their best. But let's give them the benefit of the doubt and assume they stick to the tentative dates set forth in the contract. They could still ship these things September 30th and then claim to have shipped them right on time (Q3).
2. Regarding what you actually get. They promise you 5, 50, 250Mh/s or whatever the numbers they are using now are. Notice this key phrase:
"Be advised that due to the nature of their development our products are subject to change and the final device may be different to what was advertised to you whether on our site or elsewhere."
3. And of course the escape clause:
"We shall not be liable to you for any loss of profit or for indirect or consequential loss suffered by you whether as a result of any breach of these terms by us or as a result of our negligence."
In other words, if they completely breach the contract (hard to do, since they aren't required to do much of anything but still), even if they purposefully screw you over and ship late, there is nothing you can do. You agreed to not hold them liable even if it is their fault, and even if they do it on purpose.
Thanks for pointing that out.
I understand they are not going to guarantee a delivery date. I don't have a problem with point 1. Point 2 could be a bit worrying as if those chips are not up to spec due to the nature of the quicker turn around, we are stuck. Point 3 sucks.
But what truly has me a bit worried now is what I posted above, all of Apha's posts here have been deleted (minus the quotes). That is unsettling. So, my point above about waiting for final payment until something is ready to be shipped (with CE certification) is poignant now.
IAS
ps - You didn't answer my projection question. Albeit, that is an uncomfy one.
Well I don't see how you can just dismiss point one considering that is the one we have argued about the most. And arguably is the most important. The *only* thing these devices do is mine scrypt. Exactly how much they mine is completely dependent on when they are delivered. Had these devices shipped April first, they would have been worth a fortune. If they ship September 30th, they will be near worthless. Kind of makes a huge difference no? Would be like sending 10K to coinbase to purchase bitcoins and not caring how many they send you.
Regarding your question:
"This sounds like something you would do and you are projecting it onto others. I would ship them off because I honor my word. Life is not about making as much money as I can. We reap what we sow. I'm not sure how you can judge AT when you are basically saying you would do something that you are accusing them of, because, well, it is the "natural" thing to do."
You completely miss the point. They ARE honoring their word! There is nothing dishonest about it. They never promised (in any sort of legally binding way anyways) a delivery date. The closest they came to one is September 30th shipping date. I think you misunderstand my posts. I am not judging them. Frankly, I think they were too stupid to pull off what should have been easy money but their plan itself was brilliant (albeit, stolen from others). The entire reason I posted what I did is because I DO trust them to do their best to fulfill the terms of the contract. On the other hand, I think many people such as yourself didn't actually pay any attention at all to what it was they were actually promising when you sent them all that money.
Now I DO think they were disingenuous at best regarding what they posted on the forums and stuff. But remember these were sales people. That's what salespeople do. They paint their product in the best possible light. What I was simply suggesting was to not simply take them at their "off the record" word, but look at what they were willing to put on the record. If a person tells you over and over and over again that something will ship by a certain date they are 100 percent sure of it, BUT they won't sign that into the contract, obviously they aren't nearly as sure of it as they are saying.
Where I disagree with you is, you seem perfectly willing to take their sales people's promises at face value. I on the other hand ask myself, if they are so sure of the specs and delivery dates, why aren't they willing to sign to that? This has nothing to do with my personal honesty. Simply my experience in the business world has been over and over again, that nothing anyone says is worth a damn, the only thing worth a damn is what it says in the contract. I guess we will have to agree to disagree. I can promise you though I get ripped off less often then you

If I misinderstood your post, which apparently I did, then how can we agree to disagree? Ehehehe
TBH - I have been blessed for the most part. I always have chalked it up to like attracts like with some spirit guides thrown in. ;-)
Regarding point 1, I see your point now. I was looking at it quite innocently in that they didn't have control over all the supply chain and such. Speaking of which, I look forward to blockchain tech fixing things like this via some transparent supply tracking, or something related.
I can't outright accuse AT yet as it is just hard for me to believe that someone would risk so much, potentially hurting a family name (accounting firm) just for some money, and with the possibility of jail or a severe fine.
I'm wondering why there isn't an uproar over the deleted posts. I know enough to know that is a bad sign and quite alarming.
Thanks for the information/reply,
IAS