I suggest every post with a coin suggestion, requires the poster to list their current funds of said coin

I vote darkcoin, and I own 0 of them. Its at least a little different, with active development (and you can still mine it unlike nxt). No pre-mine should also 100% be a requirement of whichever coin it is. I think active development/dev team is pretty much the next important piece, and is pretty hard to gauge. There are lots of nice older/established coins out there, but half of them seem dormant/dead/inactive these days.
CGB? Haven't heard anything in months
XPM? Awesome new concept at the time, but seems like 0 actual community pushing for anything further to happen with it