Excellent thread by @gumusi.
Here he is employing a technique known to ardent students of logic as "
Modus Tollendo Ponens" or disjunctive syllogism, which I noted with some surprise that even many of the local users he is defending seem to have missed

...
It goes like this, 1 of the following statements must be true:
Either
i) the Default Trust System is working as intended and bad actors and abusers are eliminated by the collective conscience of DT1 and BTT community
or
ii) the DT system is in ruins, and therefore this forum in its current format is considerably broken.
He then goes on to say, since the DT1 and the larger BTT community are mostly silent on the ongoing libel and black propaganda by crooked ninjas like
~jollygood and
~lauda that they end up getting represented on the DT system month after month,
the inevitable conclusion must be that the Default Trust system is a joke and serves mainly to smear strong and independent opponents for political reasons and has subtracted greatly from the prestige and brand value of Bitcointalk.
Instead of wasting time on extremely minor details and personal scuffles, please try to address the arguments from the overarching theme mentioned in the OP.
All the Best