>> (p.1)
    Author Topic: The intrinsic value debate.  (Read 283 times)
    BlackHatCoiner (OP)
    Legendary
    *
    Offline Offline

    Activity: 1792
    Merit: 8677


    View Profile
    August 12, 2021, 09:04:29 PM
    Merited by JayJuanGee (3), defi-Dany (1)
     #1

    There's lot of debate about this topic from both haters and supporters and to be honest, it's reasonable. Some people believe that if something isn't intrinsically valuable, it isn't valuable at all or shouldn't be. In this thread I'll explain why Bitcoin has no intrinsic value and why that shouldn't be a concern at all.

    First things first, I ought to define what “intrinsic value” is. It turns out that it's a tough term; it can be separated into three different meanings:

    1. Finance.
    2. Ethics.
    3. Numismatics.




    In finance, intrinsic value refers to the profit that could be gained by exercising an option. For example, if the current market value of the underlying instrument is $110, but the strike price of the option was called at $100, then its intrinsic value will be $10, ignoring what may happen to it in the future (due to price fluctuations). For example, if you bought 1 BTC at $44,000 and then sell it at $50,000, then you've gained $6,000 profit and thus, the intrinsic value of that option was $6,000.

    Note that the option has intrinsic value; not the stock/product. In this case, Bitcoin doesn't have intrinsic value financially, despite the fact that people find it valuable. Same thing happens with stocks. Their intrinsic value isn't originating from the value of the company, but from the options' profits.



    In ethics, intrinsic value is a property of an object that is valuable on its own. Pretty misleading definition, isn't it? How can you measure or understand that an object is “valuable on its own”? Wikipedia, though, puts it as following:
    Quote
    Intrinsic value is always something that an object has "in itself" or "for its own sake", and is an intrinsic property.

    So here's the problem with Bitcoin. It isn't an object. We could theoretically create a ledger which is censorship resistant from anyone and each person could manually debt each other using it, but that wouldn't make it intrinsically valuable. The people created it out of nothing; it has nothing “in itself” or “for its own sake”. I like thinking it that way: If you have two ounces of gold, you own a more intrinsically valuable total of objects that someone who owns only one ounce. But, with Bitcoin that is not true. The only thing that changes is the debt size which is paid out between humans.



    In numismatics (or commodity money), intrinsic value is the constituent metal or, simply, the “essence” that makes a medium of exchange useful beyond its exchanging purposes. A gold coin is probably the greatest example of a currency that is intrinsically valuable. Bitcoin doesn't have any essence (nor banknotes) and thus, we conclude that it is neither intrinsically valuable as a commodity money.




    So, why that madness to name its value “intrinsic”? Well, obviously, if you own Bitcoins, it is a matter of time until you make your own network effect on it; to protect your wealth! That's what we all do sometimes, aren't we? It seems that this debate had started many years ago from haters to... justify why Bitcoin has no value (?). It is completely utopian to state such thing; just think that these definitions were made long before virtuality became a commonly used word. Long before intangibility, in certain circumstances, became valuable. (e.g., Internet, Bitcoin)

    Anyway, fans had to support the choice they made with some co-arguments whether those made any sense after all. I personally think that this thing with the intrinsic value should not be brought as an argument from now on. It isn't good for neither the fans and the haters.

    • If you're a fan, you aren't proving anything by justifying why Bitcoin has intrinsic value.
    • If you're a hater, you aren't proving that Bitcoin has no value, just because it isn't intrinsically valuable.

    Peace
Page 1
Viewing Page: 1