it is not bad to buy the dip provided there is available cash for it while still using DCA as the main strategy. The only thing that is wrong with buying the dip strategy, is idea of waiting for a dip to occur before buying. There is no one that can predict or tell when a dip will occur. The best way is for an investor to continue accumulating bitcoin using DCA strategy while keeping some percentage of there discretionary income for buying the dip if it eventually occurs. The most important thing here is being consistent and at the same time setting aside some percentage of discretionary funds for buying the dip.
Holding back cash just to buy the dip isn't that waiting for the dip? And that money that person is withholding, temptation can even make the person to blow the money up on useless expenses just because the person didn't buy, but was waiting for the dip to come. I don't see why person shouldn't just use just use all the whole percentage of discretionary income they can afford to use, for their ongoing investments. Because it will be so pointless to be waiting for dip that may never happen or dip that can make person to miss out and buy at the top.
You are making a reasonable point @PhilosopherKing.
There are trade offs in waiting for the dip, even if a person might be deploying most of his discretionary funds for DCA and holding back some value for buying dips.
I am not against a duel strategy that allows for holding back value for buying dips, even though many guys tend to oversell it and act as if it is a superior strategy when it is not a superior strategy, especially when several guys may well be way better off to just make their decisions regarding how much BTC to buy every week and then perhaps they see how much they have at the end of the month too, and see if they have extra... and yeah, there could be some times that guys hold back some value to buy dips, yet they still need to recognize the trade offs in terms of the dips may or may not end up coming.
Holding back value to buy dips seems to make more sense during periods that guys might find themselves with extra value, so for some reason they received a bonus or some other lump sum amount coming available. So in those instances, they maybe had already employed their DCA, and then they have an extra amount that is available and they might want to buy some bitcoin right away with it and they are hesitating whether to use the full amount, so maybe they just use half and they hold onto to the other half and ponder over whether to invest, save and/or to discretionarily consume, and then maybe a dip comes, and they end up getting persuaded by the dip to buy some bitcoin with it.
There could be other times that buying the dip makes sense, especially with guys who may well be buying bitcoin consistently, yet there seems to be little to no reason to act as if there aren't any trade offs to be holding back value to buy dips that may or may not end up happening.
Holding back cash just to buy the dip isn't that waiting for the dip? And that money that person is withholding, temptation can even make the person to blow the money up on useless expenses just because the person didn't buy, but was waiting for the dip to come. I don't see why person shouldn't just use just use all the whole percentage of discretionary income they can afford to use, for their ongoing investments. Because it will be so pointless to be waiting for dip that may never happen or dip that can make person to miss out and buy at the top.
I don't actually knows your own definition of reserve funds, but I want you to understand that putting down reserve funds in place from your discretionary income while still accumulating consistently is not waiting for the dip as you think, because that reserve funds can be useful in the future, especially when their is a dip in the market.
Buying a dip or buying aggressively when the dip opportunity comes is never a problem as long as you are not waiting for it, because by waiting, you may miss a whole lot of buying opportunities that you should have bought and add to your stash, so it's never a wise decision to be waiting before buying, especially if you are a newbie or a no coiner that is just starting his accumulation journey.
You are just making up definitions Barikui1.
If you are holding back value to buy the dip then you are waiting, even if you are regularly buying.
There surely can be several reasons that guys want to keep extra value in cash, and even hold back some value, so guys can choose to not put high portions of their discretionary funds into their DCA and then be unable to buy any more BTC, yet there are still trade offs when holding back value, even though some guys might find it as practical to hold back value and keep it in cash for multiple reasons.. maybe they are saving up for a vacation or to go out to eat or maybe to buy a new computer or a motorcycle/auto, and maybe after several weeks, there flexible reserve funds have gotten up to more than $1k, and then they end up satisfying their other needs and they still have $500 remaining in their reserve funds, when the BTC price suddenly dips. They weren't holding those reserves specifically for the dip, but then when the dip ended up coming, they ended up being inspired to buy the dip with the $500 extra funds (in my example) that they had.
So yeah there can be multiple reasons that guys hold back value and don't buy bitcoin with it as aggressively as they could based on their own preferences, yet there is not just ONE way to do it, even though maybe we look at some guys and we might think that they would be better off to buy bitcoin with their extra money rather than some other way that they are spending their money or even that they are keeping too much cash in hand, even though those are personal choices, up to a point, until it might start to seem a bit illogical in terms of the extremes that some guys might end up taking that might not seem to be the exercising of good judgement, even though each of us is free to exercise our own judgement, even if we might sometimes come to conclusions that are inferior (even considering our own circumstances).
When we get down the road 4-10 years or longer and then we end up looking back at what we did and how much BTC we had accumulated, we may well have regrets about what we did, so in that sense, we likely have to figure out some reasonable balance in order that we do not end up having regrets down the road in regards to how whimpy or aggressive that we had chosen to be in the way that we bought bitcoin and the extent that we held back value for buying dips that may or may not end up happening.