I've held the Gold Buffalo alongside these coins and, while I am biased, I would say that these Titans have a brighter shine. We etch the dies on the sculpted areas, which is what produces the fine grain you see in those closeups. This texture really catches the light.
It's very labor intensive to get this finish right, but it adds a nice contrast that you just won't get in high production coins like the Buffalo or the American Eagle.
Well, since you brought up the Buffalo....
Basically, personally, I see the Titan being of far better quality than the US coin. I only even bought 1 Buffalo, but never again. I would rather have a regular Eagle over a Buffalo.
I would happily trade in my Buffalo for a Titan Gold. Anyone?
This goes for a redeemed coin as well.