@ ripper234
now You see why i didn't wanted it gone to wiki just yet? there is a lot of tuning left to do.
I don't think we should tune two list's at the same time, maybe in this topic we should focus on the first post list, not the wiki entry, and than You can use the data from here for wiki. If you would like to propose other categorization, make your arguments. if other's say You are right I'll change it.
No, I don't.
The tuning process is ongoing, and should continue in the wiki, that allows collaboration, and not just dictation by one individual.
I agree we shouldn't tune two lists at the same time.
Why don't you want to edit the wiki as well yourself?
right now i still think terracoin and freicoin are kind off in the middle of bearing process beacause You definitely can't say they are well established, and also it is to early to say they are dying. anyway list will be dynamic, and even if we move those to from "new on the scene" category now, the category it self will be needed in near future. We can go back to the original "bearing rising" name although. or make a new name, like "new minor bearing " .
What is "bearing"? As in "value dropping"?
I'm sorry, I don't understand your English (division into paragraphs would help).
I left the New category open for any newcomers. I'm open to other ideas, not trying to dictate anything.
The criteria I suggest for New is any coin whose design is at least 2-3 months old.
Do you agree or disagree to this criteria?
If you disagree, please provide an alternative criteria.
I don't think too much categorization is necessary at this point. Don't you like the:
1. Major
2. Minor
3. New
4. Dead/Dying?
I don't want to have to edit the wiki each wiki when a currency turns from bearish to bullish to bearish, but rather focus on long-term trends. I you think a 5th section is needed we can do that, but I'm not in favor.
