<<  >> (p.7)
    Author Topic: Forking the Blockchain for Bonds (25 BTC Bounty)  (Read 8600 times)
    phillipsjk
    Legendary
    *
    Offline

    Activity: 1008
    Merit: 1001

    Let the chips fall where they may.


    View Profile WWW
    July 16, 2011, 05:40:09 PM
     #61

    I'm worried that the bitcoin community will take an extremely rigid approach and try to avoid forks at all costs. I think excessive rigitidity will cause bitcoin to fail. If need be, I certainly plan to try to contribute towards the introduction of a new blockchain. In the meantime, I will continue to push for forking which I view as better for cryptocurrency at large.

    Finally, if one introduces a new blockchain, it is better to introduce many improvements simultaneously rather than just one. This is just one of the ones I have in mind.

    I disagree completely. I think starting a new block chain will almost always be better than forking the existing one. Forking the chain undermines the currency; thus eroding confidence and value.

    A rival blockchain is not something to be feared. There already exists the testnet and namecoin blockchains. If somebody starts up a "Bitcoin with bonds" blockchain, some people may move over to it. If you are correct that bonds are needed for long-term stability, it may even become the new "standard." It does not matter if people have money invested in the first bitcoin: If the transition happens slowly enough, the people who want to sell bitcoin can sell it in exchange for "bitcoin with bonds".

    The reason I am so cavalier about the failure of bitcoin is that I expect any crypto-currency, no matter how good, to fail in the medium-long term. Computers are just not secure enough to handle a crypto-currency in my opinion. Modern computers systems are complex and unproven. Subtle errors missed by this oversight can likely be leveraged into a devastating attack on any crypto-currency; given enough time an resources. For the record, I expect the computer industry to finally mature into reliable, proven correct systems after about 6 generations (150 years) or so. As precedent, I point to the Agricultural revolution, the invention of the wheel and the printing press. All took centuries to fundamentally change society.

    James' OpenPGP public key fingerprint: EB14 9E5B F80C 1F2D 3EBE  0A2F B3DE 81FF 7B9D 5160
Page 6
Viewing Page: 7