Let's wait to DGM, ok?
Alrighty

I appreciate you taking the time to check things out I spent a couple hours normalizing figures and doing analysis.
I take it you are not a hopper and don't really understand how it works. However, slush's scored rewards are calculated differently than a straight up prop pool So, Hopping rewards less in this pool. Plus, hoppers like to mine at the highest efficiency possible, so the opportunity cost is higher for this pool than other prop (not scored) pools. Also, the larger the pool is, the less variance hoppers can benefit from...and this is a large pool.
Reward methods like PPLNS and DGM do a better job at fairness for the miners than something you just thought of... Loyalty shares...does that mean I will get emails and a special card to shop with? Will you get a bumper sticker, too? I am not sure I understood you proposal, but I feel like we would have to wear some sort of name tag. You should open up a new thread, explain it better and see if a pool will adopt it...? You will get mega credit!!!
Lol. Ok, so I take it you didn't check out the analysis I did proving that pool hopping was affecting pay on short blocks.
And apparently, you're not literate enough to understand my idea, but you know those other ideas work better.
Wow. I'm in the company of a genius.