I'm showing 5 x more unexchanged 

http://middlecoin2.s3-website-us-west-2.amazonaws.com/reports/1M9B8YxAXRLzSR3J74kZe8uA18ZCQGZFCh.html

For those who are saying they got the best payout yet, what server were you on and how long have you been mining. I've been mining for 20 days on the US server, and yesterday was not a good payout. I was under the impression all servers were running the same code now...

Yes. If you got less than 0.01, but more than 0.001, then the remainder will be paid out after 7 days.

It is the same code, but it's not always the same coins we're mining and it's not always the same amount of coins being traded in.

I think the confusion for some people is that this isn't one big social all mine, all share pool.
The pool keeps track of what you've mined and when you've mined it. You can't directly compare your 2Mh/s with someone else 2Mh/s, not even on the same server.
Some of his coins might have sold, while yours haven't. Your coins will sell next day, with a higher priority of course.
Or a particular coin can crash and h2o will have to sit on it for several days before he can trade it.
The altcoin market is very fluid and he's moving coins generated from over 11Gh/s of mining power these days.

My point is that it's not just a simple y Mh/s = x dollars formula, and it never will be. It's a lot more complicated than this.

And for what it's worth, today's payout was average for me, nothing special. But I got a ton of unexchanged coins, so it'll be better tomorrow.

This pool might have become too big to be significantly more profitable than LTC, even as profitable is not easily attainable. Victim of it's own simplicity and success.

Profits have been steadily declining, particularly visible in the last few days, and IMHO not nearly as profitable as top 5 coins. I've almost got tears in my eyes seeing the missed profit, and the lack of time to do anything about it. Yes, we're big so it's simply not possible to mine the most profitable coins, due to insufficient market depth for them, so we must settle for bigger, less profitable ones. That defeats the very purpose of the profitability pool. If the target was a "stable, no hassle pool with medium profitability", we could probably be reaching it, if there wasn't for all the beta testing, which, when you want to keep your customers, is usually not rolled out without sufficient testing. I do SW development coordination for living. I would lose my job if I did beta testing with real customers, on production systems. My job is to prevent that.

Op's lack of transparency is understandable, the pool hashrate is still growing, so good PR, or even any,  PR is obviously not needed to run the business as enough hash will come in anyway. I would certainly not run it that way, but it seems that there's a lot of followers who see nothing wrong with it, so it can't be expected to improve. With this income, there is room for investing a part of it in building a loyal customer base, to build a lifelong business, not a one time off deal. Even though the money is good, it will not last for a lifetime.

I wouldn't call this pool a business, a real business would at least have some kind of contact/address/registration information.

I think the whole mining pool scene is more of a wild-west fronteering situation I think..

Hmm.. Fronteering or frontiering? Judging from the urban dictionary entry for frontiering, definitely not that one

Question, does the value of unexchanged coins get updated? What I mean is, when coins get added to unexchanged they have a certain BTC value at that moment in time, however they might be a lot lower or higher a few hours after while remaining unexchanged. I'm building up a lot of unexchanged and wondering if the value is reported accurately.

It should convert over, my understanding was that was the BTC price we got paid for it, but we are still waiting for it to come off the exchanges which can take a while. The immature funds are more likely to change in price because we are waiting for those to come out of the blockchain.

It's definitely a business for h2o! He's pulling in over $3,000 PER DAY. That's $1,095,000 a year!

And that's not counting how much he makes off of cryptsy points through auto trading

Well the business, or endeavor, is what you make it. You can do it wild west style, or you can do it the proper way. I would spend up to 30% of the cash on hiring people for PR and stability improvements, but that's just me. Take a look at how the hashcows handled their big issue, that's how you handle problems. Now if only I didn't have a well paid job and a family, and had a little bit more hair.... oh wait, that's not needed

Anyway - times were good for a while, people could put up with issues while the profits were high, but now the focus should move to stability, support and PR. A lot of people invested their hard earned cash into rigs, and that should, must, be treated with respect.