I'm being asked by various members in the Computer Hardware forum to post ALL of my offers into one topic instead of creating separate topics per offer.
To me, this is going to make it very difficult to manage, because I am a broker who has multiple brands and models and multiple buyers and sellers. Putting all my items into one post will make the Computer Hardware forum almost useless for me.
Others are afraid that if I post separate topics for each offer that I have, it will clog up Page 1, but to me, making separate posts makes it much more relevant and competitive in a good way. Not in a bad way. They think I'm trying to push down other people's posts to Page 2, but that is not my intention.
Honestly, I think older post SHOULD get naturally pushed to Page 2 because they are... OLDER. But what these people are trying to tell me is that they want all my offers to be in one post. This will quickly cause my single post to get out of hand. It will soon have hundreds of replies. and will quickly become the #1 post on the Computer Hardware forum at all times.
I don't think you guys want that to happen, do you? You say you want the Computer Hardware forum to be "clean", but in my opinion, posting multiple offers into a single post will make the forum a jumbled mess and very confusing for the OP.
The Forum guidelines say:
After the sale...
- Update the thread title as either Sold, Closed, or something suitable
- Post in the thread the outcome, this helps provide insight as to whether a valid trade transaction place
- Lock the thread once finished, and updated. Once all relevant information has been shared there is no need to leave it open, as it may get bumped months later.
So, by abiding by those guidelines, my post will either be updated multiple times per day, forcing it to be the first listing in the forum every day, or it will be impossible for me to lock it and let it die.
Which do you want. We can't have both, we can't have all or nothing. We need a compromise.