Since bitcoin has an event every 210,000 blocks whose timing roughly correlates to an occurance once every four years, how about timing the event to one fourth of that 210,000 blocks...
Why does it have to be every year? Why can't it be every four years like the Olympics or the World Cup. It will make it a more special celebration people will look forward to.
The block-parties every 210,000 blocks will surely happen anyway, so we already have such a very special celebration.
It can't hurt though to have another Bitcoin day to celebrate every year and a floating date according to block-height would be very appropriate. I like the 52,500th block idea since it is the most logical one, but it will probably stay in winter for a long time. Anyway, here's a few alternatives from the top of my head:
- Once every 50,000 blocks or roughly 11.6 months. Pretty intuitive, would not collide with the block-partys and soon be in summer. Projected dates for the next 5 years:
- 2012: October 1st
- 2013: September 13th
- 2014: August 26th
- 2015: August 8th
- 2016: July 21st
- Once every 2^16=65536 blocks or roughly every 15 months. Would not collide with a block-party within the next 50,000 years but there would be years without a Bitcoin day and it is probably a bit too nerdy - even for Bitcoin

Projected dates for the next 5 years:
- 2012: September 7th
- 2013: December 6th
- 2014: none
- 2015: March 6th
- 2016: June 4th
- Pick a good (notable) calendar date and take the nearest 10,000th block. That would mean it could only vary about +-2 months around that day and therefore stay roughly in the same season every year.
- Celebrate the 10th difficulty adjustment every year. Would always be around spring.
- Countdown to the last Satoshi. The block with the last Satoshi ever to be mined will be 6,929,999. Divide that by 100 and you have kind of a percentage counter for Bitcoin which will increase roughly every 16 months. A nice property but maybe too long a cycle. Projected dates for the next 5 years:
- 2012: November 25th
- 2013: none
- 2014: March 21st
- 2015: July 15th
- 2016: November 7th