snip
The rhetorical response is not going to help it.
Take another ex; Shakib was not out today but the umpire gave him out. Does that mean ICC deliberately helped Pakistan? No, it was just a dumb call from the 3rd umpire. No one making any fuss about it. Hope you get the gist.
Off-the-field politics is a different matter and you like it or not, it's there to stay due to a power struggle but when teams are playing or competing on the ground, ICC can't do shit.
Do Umpires make mistakes? Yeah, they do and it's bound to happen, sometimes decisions benefit one team sometimes the opposition.
Fans and experts have a choice, keep playing the victim cards/look for conspiracy theories or simply move on. The majority opt for the latter.
I understand the point that you are making. I am definitely not opposed to anything that you have said. However, I have not seen this type of mistake being made in any other sport, at least not recently.
Especially with all the technology available right now it is quite surprising that mistakes like this are being made in cricket!!
I agree that mistakes can be made. To err is human. But when you have the appropriate tools available, you should not make mistakes, that's what I believe. I literally do not understand how a third umpire can make mistakes. There is an unwritten rule that if something is 50/50 the benefit of the doubt goes to the batsman. But we also see things happening the other way around as well.
If it was up to BCCI then they would've liked a PIG-1 system where they alone taking a lion share but it's not possible at all unless they take some drastic steps, which no one would like.
There is no big 4 bhai. it's only Ind+Aus+Eng.
I would prefer a pig-1 system when compared to pig-4. Let ECB and CA get a taste of their own medicine. I would still use the term pig-4, because CNZ is more rabid than any of the other three cricket boards in their hatred towards the associate nations. And as a reward for their hatred, they have their guy as the chairman of the ICC. For the elections, Barclay will be having the confirmed support from India, NZ, Australia, England and Oman. CSA went with the pig-4 last time in the second round. WICB and Afghanistan Cricket Board may also go with pig-4.
Why is there even a system like this?
There should be equal rights for every team. Which apparently ICC is unable to provide. I actually agree that things are looking like it is going to be another big three or four systems. But with that, I think the future of cricket is doomed. Additionally, if systems like this continue to be implemented on smaller teams or associate countries who may not be able to play cricket regularly, that eventually means better revenue for the ICC.