Indeed a human is just an animal with a slightly higher level of reasoning. If you offer the animal unlimited free, addictive food (e.g. sugar or MSG laden), it eats and eats until it dies of obesity. Would you like to McUpSize that.
Mancur Olsen's
The Logic of Collective Action explains this well.
In Europe the McUpSize has been on humanism rather than America's fatfood craze ("you are a liberated woman in control of your own body and that is why you can fuck anything you want to including but limited to you another woman's tongue and never bear offspring"). Europeans see themselves as more sophisticated socialist pigs.
The only way I can envision to squelch this phenomenon is to make it economically impossible to form top-down enforced collectives larger than a local community, i.e. remove the capability to form a power vacuum of control that must be filled by power (with corruption being naturally the most powerful mode). Local community reputation (within our Dunbar limit) naturally contain abusive excesses ("you are a fat lardass", "you are a disgusting dyke" says your neighbor). All my work on making anonymous decentralized crypto, is about making it impossible for a collective to exist per Max Weber's canonical definition, "State is a monopoly on the use of force".
I don't believe in anarchistic anything. To believe that such a system would work you have to believe that individuals are inherently good. I believe that in general individuals gravitate towards being inherently bad
Individuals can't do that much bad against a society where citizens can carry guns.
Rather it is the collective organization of individuals that empowers the State to have the might to enact horrific megadeath.
Yea europeans (I am european but i`m exception) have a highly sensitive social belonging crave. I see this is almost every country I visited, and not just in old people, but in every age group. Europe is collectivist by genetics.
Americans are more freedom and individual oriented, after all they went in 1700-1800 there from various places of the world. In Europe there were already welfare states in the 1800s, and they left to America just because they had individual freedom and economic freedom. So in my view American culture is higher one, unfortunately, they are social engineering it into a pitfall with all these stupid things that come out.
Africans are more tribal oriented, could be leftist or not, but alteast they focus more on family and localism, so its also a better local community focus and hardly care about the big picture.
Asians are also collectivists, for i dont know what reason.
So it can be a genetic thing, but also a cultural one.
The only way I can envision to squelch this phenomenon is to make it economically impossible to form top-down enforced collectives larger than a local community, i.e. remove the capability to form a power vacuum of control that must be filled by power (with corruption being naturally the most powerful mode).
In my view you can never get rid of leftists, its just part of human nature. But what can you do is to decentralize them. Instead of a giant zombie collective controlling all our lives with rabid greed and envy, if you decentralize leftism into local community pockets, it can become much manageable, and more responsible.
Take for example a leftist village, if the peasants get very lazy, and they dont work on the crops, they die of hunger, but if they get outside welfare from the next village, they will survive, and they will be lazy aswell.
But if you dont give them help, and let the village do what they can to survive, then even though you will still find 2-3 lazy peasant, the rest of them will work, and because of social pressure, outcasting, and perhaps severe criticism, they will begin eventually to work.
See some people never grow up, 30-40-50-60 year old people acting like 5 year olds, they might need some "parents" who straighten them out.
So in my example above, if you create many leftist villages that manage themselves by social pressure and outcasting lazy peasants who dont work, then you can achieve a much reasonable society, than with global socialism, where I pay for people 3000 km away to eat and drink and watch TV all day from their lazy unemployed asses, and they don't even mail me a letter saying "Thanks bro"...