I get that, Pool owners want monney and so did not want to refuse some Power.
Users want better service and don't care. Even if you close the registration, the hash will not get away, it will remain the same for a while.
If you raise the fee when you go over 45% (for example), user will start to go away, and the pool owner will get more fees, it seems like a win-win solution.
If all the pools agree to do the same, public oppinion will not be hurted as soon as the fees will get back to normal when the Hash get out of the critical range.
Another method I've seen employed is to ddos the pool with 50% hashrate. Not a nice way of taking care of the problem . . but incredibly effective.
I can understand that most pools that hit 45% and greater aren't looking to cause problems . . but it really makes the coin look weak.
Coinmine is doing a very decent job as a pool and he's simply picking up the people that leave other pools because he's doing a better job. Should he be DDOSed for that? I think he was relatively cooperative, yet when the official pool went down for changes, the hashrate of coinmine exploded again (which is natural as he picked up a few extra gigahashes). Then the official pool didn't recover the hashrate after the server transfer and also had the orphan problem etc etc. So, naturally, people will opt for what works.
A simple email or pm to an understanding pool owner will do the trick in most cases. I think, from what I've read in his public responses, that he understands the issue, but then again what can he do with the network spikes when a large pool goes down and people use him as a failover? Even if he aims for a 30% market, he can still find himself at >50% on a day where 2 other pools are DDOSed, or are down for whatever reason. We simply need more pools that have a decent hashrate to avoid variance penalties and are operated in a smooth way so that people can diversify their hashrate. P2Pools are good as a concept but I'm getting too many issues, rejects etc. The situation is getting better for sure, relative to one month ago, as there are now much more options to choose from. And it'll probably get better with time.