I should have earned .016+ BTC and got nothing for it instead as well. This is my second day and I've paid out a lot for mining rental equipment so this is a real BLACK mark on this pool, in my eyes.

*smirk* there are soo many reasons why you might not have received your $10, the most obvious being that you paid for renting mining equipment.
alternatively:
1) pool luck - its not uncommon to go 24hrs without the pool solving a block some days, and other days solving 10 blocks
2) your machines not properly connecting to the pool - whats the reported hashrate?
3) payout is delayed for 120 blocks if i recall (~20hrs) so whatever you earned may be 'pending' still
4) the first bit of time on the pool will have very low rewards until the PPLNS system reaches its peak for your system. (I think this takes 10 blocks?)