before coming to any false conclusions without any facts.
How do you know what is false and what is fact?

Please, tell us the facts you know.
He says: The devs should explain.
You answer: Explain.

He is right. The devs only should "explain". But since the code is still not open, they wont. As far as I can tell from my experience, the PoI seems to work great though.
He said : mattadc (and Conurtol) had false args,
I said : we (including him) don't know the facts.
He can prove that the above is wrong

Should we stop every discussion, when we are not 100 % sure about something? Not.