There is a need to do both, yet if guys get quite out of balance, then greater chances come that he is going to be forced into a more balanced position.
This is why it's worth having at least 3-6 months expenses. Not just in case of an unexpected vet bill. Thats not enough.
at least 3-6 months of expenses is a lot, even for someone who had been building his bitcoin for a while.
It could take a couple of years for guys to get up to having 3 months expenses in cash and also 3 months or more of expenses invested into bitcoin .
You may have noticed that job losses tend to correlate well with drawdowns in BTC. In both 2020 and 2022, BTC dropped by 50%+ at the same time there were surges in layoffs. This can be devastating for crypto investors:
We are not investing in crypto. That would be retarded.
When we are buying bitcoin, we are looking at our own situation, rather than if there happens to be job losses accross various industries, so it is not really clear what you want to say about how any of us might be approaching bitcoin.
You have ONLY been registered here for a month, so have you yet started accumulating bitcoin and/or building up your back up funds?
Maybe you are talking a lot of theory, yet in practice, we are going to be figuring out our own situation that might include whether we have current income coming in and/or if we might expect our income situation to change, and then the same may well be true in regards to figuring out our basic expenses and the extent to which our income covers all of our basic expenses so that we have money left over (aka discretionary income) that we can use for buying bitcoin, saving and/or discretionary consumption.
\
If you lose your job at the same time your portfolio is down 50%, then youre going to be tempted to sell at the bottom.
Well when we are investing in bitcoin we are taking a certain amount from our discretionary funds to invest in bitcoin and another part for savings, and if we have been building up our bitcoin and out back up funds (savings) for several years, then we will be in a place to weather longer periods of loss of income, and so surely, we should also probably be striving to seek jobs that give us some job security too. If we cannot establish some level of job security, then we might not have confidence that we are able to continue to buy bitcoin, so of course, there could be greater needs to save up greater amounts of money for loss of our job if we don't have any confidence in our ability to continue to be able to work as compared with guys who might have jobs and income that they consider to be more reliable.
If you have an adequate cash cushion, then a drawdown is nothing but a temporary paper loss. Once the 3-6 months of expenses is fully funded, only then should one think about investing in BTC or anything else.
Guys do not have to save 3-6 months of expenses before investing into bitcoin.
Guys can start investing into bitcoin with almost no back up funds as long as they have discretionary funds, and surely, it is probably important that guys have enough back up funds to cover them until their next paycheck, but there is no reason that back up funds have to be built prior to bitcoin holdings unless the guy has such unreliable income that ongoingly, he has no confidence in continued employment. Many times guys should be able to build up systems in which they are never tapping into their emergency funds even after 4-10 years or longer of investing.
Sometimes guys might also need to consider if they might be able to increase their job skills and experiences so that they don't have as much job (income) insecurity as you are proclaiming to be present for many guys... and sure there are guys who have bad situations and without discretionary funds, and maybe they should not be investing in bitcoin.
At the same time, if guys are ongoingly focusing on building up back up funds, such as 3-6 months or more, then they may well end up having fun staying poor forever since cash and back up funds are not going to have any potential for growth, and most likely cash and back up funds are going to end up losing value faster than they can be built, especially once such back up funds get to be greater than 3 months of expenses.
Someone who's income changes monthly and someone with a stable salary and low expenses this two people will have different needs.
However, the reason it's longer for self-employed/freelance/commission-based people is because it takes them longer to regain income (and there's no employer to fall back on), and it's less predictable how long that will be, so they're advised to have about twice as much, hence the 6-12 months, or more. The old standard piece of financial planning advice is 3-6 months of expenses for people with steady, reliable, salaried income.
+ This is helpful because it takes some nebulous "it depends" advice and gives some hard and useful numbers.
Your hard numbers are not very useful since they seem to overly emphasize keeping high levels of cash, which would be a never ending and losing game to be holding so much of that crap and failing/refusing to invest in bitcoin when bitcoin is amongst the best, if not the best place to put value.
I agree with you that guys who might be running their own business, they may well have to maintain higher levels of back up funds, but your numbers of holding 6-12 months of cash would be difficult to maintain, even for rich folk since such cash would be losing 5-10% or more per year in value.. so you are just spinning wheels merely to keep such large quantities of cash... and so your advice is pretty fucking bad, especially for guys who are trying to figure out ways to build a bitcoin investment.